Open Educational Standard · Free for Practitioners

Reviewer Training and Participation Record

Six self-paced modules and a companion desk reference for deciding whether a record can still explain its own conclusion, particularly where AI-assisted drafting has contributed to it. Built for compliance, HR, audit, legal, AI governance and investigative reviewers. Module 1 opens with no sign-up.

Written by Phillip Wikes, former Lead Civil Rights Officer, Maryland Commission on Civil Rights, M.S. Negotiation and Conflict Management. The research samples must be distinguished: 16 independent detection-panel reviewers each examined 24 constructed records, while a separate reliability analysis used 104 determinations from 22 analyzed raters. These findings do not establish operational effectiveness. Read the study results and limitations.

Six modules, worked at your own pace

Each module ends in a short applied exercise. Progress saves in your browser, so you can stop and come back. The full set takes most reviewers two to three hours.

Module 01

JRS Review Conditions

The five conditions themselves: reconstructability, basis identification, chronology, decision-process traceability, evidentiary sufficiency. What each one asks and what a failure looks like.

Module 02

Common Documentation Conditions

The patterns that recur across real records: conclusions without a stated basis, chronologies that cannot be followed, and characterizations with no visible source.

Module 03

Secondary Review and Escalation

What a second reviewer needs from a file, when a record should be returned to the drafter, and how to write an escalation that survives being read a year later.

Module 04

AI-Assisted Record Review

Reviewing records that a model helped draft. Polished prose can hide missing evidence and untraceable reasoning, and the same five conditions still apply.

Module 05

Investigation Review

Applying the conditions to investigative files: interview records, evidence handling, and whether the finding can be rebuilt from the file alone.

Module 06

Implementation Sequence

Putting pre-finalization review into an existing workflow without adding a stage, and what to report to leadership.

Companion desk reference included
The Rapid Review Card: a one-page reference for applying the five conditions live, during a review, without opening the training. Free, no form.
Open the card ↓
Detection accuracy
83.9%
16 independent experts on the detection panel against a verified key, read blind. 95% CI 72.7 to 95.1.
Inter-rater reliability
0.739
Gwet's AC1 among experts, 0.623 among trained reviewers. Interim: wide intervals on 10 records.
Cross-vendor agreement
66.7–93.3%
Three AI vendors applying the same conditions to the same constructed record set. Across 61 recorded runs, 12 June to 21 August 2026, the range was 66.7 to 93.3 percent, mean 85.3 percent, and 82.2 to 93.3 percent across 37 runs at the full 15-record set. The study closed on 21 August 2026.
Reviewer base
58
International reviewers have graded records for this work, unpaid and in a personal capacity.

Every figure is recomputed from the study database rather than transcribed. The two reported as interim have not met their pre-registered secondary criterion and say so. Full detail on the research and validation page.

01Read the training. All six modules open with no sign-up, no email and no account. Decide on the material rather than on a promise.
02Name your participation record if you wish. All modules remain free without registration. A name can be placed on a locally generated completion image. Email is only requested if you independently opt into an optional named server-held enrollment record.
03Work the six modules. Each ends in an applied exercise. Stop and return whenever you like.
04Generate your participation record. The optional local image documents self-attested module completion. It does not establish a scored assessment, independent competence, a professional credential, or a LinkedIn certification.
05Submit the reviewer evaluation. Optional. A short anonymized baseline on how records are reviewed where you work. This is the research contribution and it carries no certificate of its own.
JRS is an open educational method, not a licence or accreditation. Training progress is self-attested, and the optional local completion image reflects participation only. No university, government body or professional association certifies competence through this training.

Start the training

No sign-up is required. All six modules are accessible now, and a name is optional if you choose to generate a personal participation record.

Open the training

Free access · No credit card · All six modules open straight away