A record can look complete and still fail.
Use this check to see whether a later reader can trace the record’s evidence and reasoning.
Check one record now
Use one closed record. Tick each question you would answer no or unsure. Your selections stay in this browser. How this site handles data.
This check does not score your record. There is no registration, no account, no upload.
A decision can be correct and its record still unable to explain why it was reached. Months later, when someone challenges it, the file is what answers: not the reasoning that happened in the room. Decision Reconstruction Risk is the gap between the two, and AI-assisted drafting widens it, because a generated draft reads as finished long before it is defensible.
The seven failure modes
The record reads well and reaches a confident conclusion, but no identifiable source evidence supports it.
Detection questionPoint to the sentence that states the conclusion. Now point to the evidence it rests on. Can you?
A summary or paraphrase stands in for the underlying evidence, so the reader cannot verify the claim.
Detection questionWhere the record says what a document or witness said, can a reader reach the document itself?
Events and evidence are asserted without a dated sequence, so the timeline cannot be reconstructed.
Detection questionCan you put the events in order from the record alone, with dates?
The path from evidence to conclusion is skipped; the record states the result without the connective reasoning.
Detection questionBetween the evidence and the finding, is the reasoning written down or assumed?
The record is definite in tone but vague in substance, giving the appearance of completeness without its content.
Detection questionStrike every confident adjective. Is there anything specific left?
The cited evidence does not actually support the strength of the stated conclusion.
Detection questionDoes the evidence support the finding as written, or only a weaker version of it?
The record cites a rule, precedent, or source that cannot be located or checked from the record itself.
Detection questionTake one cited authority. Could a stranger find it from what the record says?
Research evidence
The five conditions behind the check
The seven modes are symptoms. The five review conditions are what a JRS reader assesses, defined in the JRS Codebook. Each is at Experimental maturity, which is stated plainly rather than implied away.
Could a reader who was not there rebuild the decision from the record alone?
Is the basis for each material claim identified and reachable?
Can the sequence of events and evidence be established from the record?
Is the path from evidence to conclusion visible rather than assumed?
Is the documented evidence enough to support the conclusion drawn?
Take it further
If a documentation gap appears, identify the missing source, date, authority or reasoning and note what needs verification within your authorized process. Preserve the original record and distinguish unresolved gaps from confirmed findings. See the three-step reviewer procedure. The number of boxes selected is not a score or a determination that the decision is incorrect.
Individual record-review services are not offered. JRS remains in operational validation. This free check is intended for practitioners applying the published guidance within their existing workflows. For questions about the resources, visit Contact JRS.
Not what you came for?
After using the seven questions, you may separately evaluate whether the instrument identifies gaps that routine documentation review could overlook. This optional, approximately four-minute evaluation concerns the method, not your confidential case records. JRS remains in operational validation; participation is not evidence of adoption or endorsement.
Pressure-test the standard (4-minute evaluation) →
What this page does not do. It does not score your record, and it does not expose the scoring logic or the benchmark answer key used in the validation studies. It is a reading aid. JRS is designed to support organizational governance, auditability, documentation traceability, and review processes that may be relevant to frameworks and regulatory requirements such as the EU AI Act and NIST AI RMF. It does not establish legal or regulatory compliance, and no framework requires it.